The Embroidery Hoop Talk – How to find the perfect embroidery hoop

The Hoop Talk: What to look for when you buy a new embroidery hoop
by

How to find a good quality embroidery hoop

Embroidery hoops in any form recently are THE tool for everything according to my Pinterest feed and many websites I frequently visit. Usage covers framing, towel holders, bag closures and whatnot. It’s great to see this versatile thing which impersonated the oldfashioned housewife somehow for a long while receiving modern attention. There are some examples below in this post!

All the embroidery hoops I have are either vintage GDR hoops or those I bought at a local store. All of these hoops are of very good quality and mostly manufactured in Germany. When sadly my local store shut down last month I was looking for a new source and looked over at ebay. I never would have thought that there would be THIS badly made embroidery hoops out there, because I never saw some in my life. Now I did.

I bought a bunch of embroidery hoops declared as 2. choice for a steal. I knew if these would turn out not good enough for embroidering the price would not hurt and I would find other ways to use them. These were REALLY bad, but at least I knew this could happen. Then I got another bunch of hoops for double the price – not much better. So I looked to DMC embroidery hoops and it’s really hard to get these over here in Germany (most search results where my own shops). I had 18cm/7inch DMC hoops in my shops until the end of 2013.
So, now you have the advantage to learn out of my failure in buying a proper embroidery hoop and spare you a lot of money! Here are the things you should pay attention to when buying an embroidery hoop whether in person or via pictures (aka catalogues or the internet):

The Hoop Talk: What to look for when you buy a new embroidery hoop

1. The closure

You can spot a bad embroidery hoop by the closure quite quickly. A good closure looks sturdy and closes tightly.
Here is a comparison shot between a good (brass) and a bad (silver) embroidery hoop closure. The good one has a sturdy and quite thick metal base with rounded edges. The screw is fixated on the right and pulls the hoop together through the thread in the left part of the base. The silver closure has very thin metal parts which are likely to bend over time and make it impossible to regulate the tension properly then. The part on the left looking like a nut (the metal “nut”) is attached to the base to pull the hoop together. I had one hoop of the same kind where this nut wasn’t attached to the base anymore and therefore it was impossible to tighten the screw. This makes the embroidery hoop completely useless unless you are willing to tighten your hoop with 2 pliers every time.

The Hoop Talk: What to look for when you buy a new embroidery hoop

 2. The wood

The material of the embroidery hoop is very important. I found most low quality hoops are made out of bamboo or balsa wood and the good ones out of hardwood (e.g. beechwood). If a company decides to use the more expensive hardwood, it’s more likely they pay attention to the quality of the embroidery hoop overall. It would not make any sense for a manufacturer to buy expensive material for a 1$ product, right? I’m not saying there are no good bamboo or balsa wood hoops out there, I just never saw one.

The surface of the hoop should be smoothly polished, no splintering especially not on the inside where both rings meet and where also your precious textiles will be sitting in.

The Hoop Talk: What to look for when you buy a new embroidery hoop

 3. The fit

Below is an example of the extreme – a huge gap between the inner and outer ring – that’s a big no for this hoop! Remember: The hoop is there to hold consistent tension for your fabric. If there is a gap, there is no chance to get the tension right at this spot.

The perfect fitting of the outer and inner ring is the most important thing to look for because you can’t fix this afterward.

The Hoop Talk: What to look for when you buy a new embroidery hoop

Is there a good embroidery hoop out there at all???

After these shocking news on bad hoops here is a save spot: Look out for hardwood hoops and take a close look at the closure (these are often shown on product photography, sometimes only small). Beechwood is a little bit reddish in comparison to other hardwoods, bamboo is yellowish and has a distinct grain. So if you look for embroidery hoops online, see if any of these keywords pop up in the item description.

I prefer DMC hoops and Hardwicke Manor Hoops. They have the same closure and finishing, I think they are both the same (but I don’t know for sure!). Both are easily available in the US.

The cheap wooden hoops at dollar stores or sold in bundles are most likely to be of the kind I showed you above in the pictures!

 

Already have a bad hoop?

So now you probably have some embroidery hoops that are not perfect and don’t know what to do with? Remember the bad hoops are just bad for embroidering itself. Cheap embroidery hoops are great to do crafty things with them – I would not use my quality hoops for these! If your hoop is splintering, take out fine sanding paper and rubb these nasty needles off before they get in your fingers. Paint/spray them and use as colorful hoop frame. There are also people who wrap their embroidery hoops in masking tape (this would spare you the sanding of a splintery hoop).

I created a Pinterest board with a lot of hoop craft inspiration. There are some gems in there:

pinhoop

Now you know what to look for quality-wise but which size should you buy? The Hoop Talk continues with this article about embroidery hoop size!

More about Hoops!

This post is part of the Embroidery Hoop Talk Series. You might be interested in the other posts, too! Check this for the whole list of Embroidery Hoop Talks.

The Ultimate Hoop Guide

The Ultimate Hoop Guide - free printable with all the important data about wooden embroidery hoops

Can’t remember all the stuff about hoops? Get your free printable with all the rules of thumb and measurements about embroidery hoops!


Pimp your embroidery hoop

The Hoop Talk: What to look for when you buy a new embroidery hoop
Share

Anne is an embroidery enthusiast living in rural north eastern Germany.

Comments

  1. […] If you have struggles with buying an embroidery hoop, here is an article on what to look for! […]

  2. […] a series of articles all around embroidery hoops. It has started 2014 with the first articles about how to find a good quality hoop and how to find the perfect size of hoop for […]

  3. Hi, i need to find the cheapest hoops possible. It’s not for embroidery, i don’t even need the tightening hardware– just the wood hoops. I run a nonprofit education project for disadvantaged teenagers. The cheapest I found was on eBay, about $2 each incl shipping. Can you refer me to someplace where i can find them cheaper? Thx! John, California USA.

  4. Great post! You have a lot of great information, thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is using WP Check Spammers from Xavier Media to filter out spam comments.